Creating a Deal Flow Machine

There are tens of thousands of businesses for sale every day across the country, but they’re not going to show up at your front door asking to be bought. The businesses with unique value propositions are typically privately transacted, as opposed to being listed on public business directories. Finding these hidden gems requires a thoughtful and strategic approach in an ultra-competitive market. 

We sat down with Christi Loucks, Founder of Howdy Sales and Managing Director at Heritage Oaks Holdings for a live workshop where she shared practical tips and advice on proprietary deal sourcing, so you can transact on attractive businesses that other buyers will miss.

Why proprietary sourcing matters

Proprietary deal sourcing means finding acquisition opportunities that aren't publicly listed. These hidden opportunities often have less competition, potentially better pricing, and more room for negotiation. By developing a unique sourcing strategy, you're more likely to discover high-quality businesses that align closely with your investment goals.

Here’s what you can do to improve your proprietary sourcing:

1. Build a clear investment thesis

Before starting your search, clearly define what you're looking for. This is your investment thesis. Include criteria such as industry focus, size, location, financial performance, and growth potential. Having a clear thesis helps you quickly evaluate opportunities and communicate effectively with potential sellers.

2. Leverage professional and personal networks

Your existing network is often the richest source of deals. Regularly engage with friends, colleagues, former coworkers, and industry professionals. Attend industry events and conferences to meet business owners who might be open to a future sale. Be proactive — let your network know you're actively seeking acquisition opportunities.

3. Engage directly with business owners

One of the most effective methods of proprietary sourcing is directly reaching out to business owners. 

What’s important is that you’re able to “cut through the noise because business owners are hit up left and right by searchers.”

Personalized, respectful outreach often yields the best responses. Be clear about your interest and intentions, and avoid overly aggressive or transactional language. 

Christi advises targeting the initial messaging around “preserving what they’ve built.” You’ll have time to talk about yourself and your committed capital down the line, but upfront, the “messaging needs to be about them—their legacy, their employees, their next chapter.”

This initial connection should focus on building rapport and exploring mutual fit, rather than rushing into negotiation.

4. Utilize industry databases and resources

While personal outreach is vital, supplementing your efforts with tooling and databases can significantly widen your scope. 

“Weirdly enough, we’re getting our best results right now by using tools like Clay and scrapers like Apify, not the big traditional databases like Grata,” Christi notes.

Here are some other options to access prospect data:

You can also use tools like industry association directories, local chamber of commerce listings, and professional organizations to identify potential targets. These databases help you create focused lists of businesses that meet your criteria.

5. Utilize industry databases and resources

While personal outreach is vital, supplementing your efforts with tooling and databases can significantly widen your scope. 

Building strong relationships with brokers, investment bankers, accountants, and lawyers can yield valuable referrals and opportunities. These professionals often have knowledge of businesses that may soon come to market. Cultivating these relationships requires patience and consistency, but it's highly effective in accessing off-market deals.

Importantly, though, you have to be selective with the intermediaries you work with. While good brokers, for example, can help you close a transaction, bad brokers (which there are many of) can kill a deal before you have a chance to salvage it. 

6. Offer value beyond the deal

When approaching sellers, consider how you can offer value beyond just purchasing their business. Understand their motivations and pain points. For many sellers, it’s about “keeping their people employed and preserving the name on the door.” 

Tailoring your pitch to address specific seller needs can significantly enhance your proposition.

Pro tip: Owners care more about who’s taking over their life’s work than they do about your resume.

7. Maintain persistence and discipline

Successful deal sourcing requires consistent effort and discipline. Establish a structured process, set measurable goals for outreach, and regularly evaluate your progress. Being methodical ensures your pipeline remains robust and keeps opportunities flowing steadily.

Additional tips for effective proprietary sourcing

• Local and community involvement: Getting involved in local community activities or industry groups can organically connect you with business owners who might become sellers down the line.

• Tailored communication: Your communications should always be personalized to the business and its owner. Make your outreach relevant to the recipient by referencing their business specifically.

• Thoughtful follow-up: Not every conversation leads immediately to a deal. Keep in regular contact and be genuinely helpful and interested, even if a seller isn't ready yet. This patience can pay dividends in the future when the time is right.

Common pitfalls to avoid

• Lack of preparation: Approaching business owners without adequate preparation or clarity on your investment criteria can undermine your credibility.

• Transactional mindset: Prioritize relationship-building over immediate transactions. Business owners are more likely to engage seriously if they feel you're genuinely interested in their story and the future of their business.

• Poor communication: Ensure your outreach is professional, concise, and courteous. Avoid overly aggressive tactics or unrealistic promises.

Making your proprietary sourcing strategy work

Building a deal pipeline of proprietary off-market deals isn’t quick or easy—it requires intentionality, planning, and persistence. However, mastering it provides a powerful advantage, uncovering valuable acquisition opportunities that might otherwise remain hidden. By building genuine relationships, leveraging networks strategically, and consistently refining your approach, you'll position yourself to access compelling acquisition opportunities others overlook.

Thanks again to Christi for sharing her insights in the Mainshares Network! You can get in touch with her on Linkedin or Howdy Sales.

Join our upcoming live workshops

Every week, we host tactical sessions with experienced operators and deal experts. Connect with 3,000+ SMB buyers, investors, and owners inside the Mainshares Network.